Skip to main content

Why India is called as a Union of States and not a Federation?

INDIA: UNION OF STATES

Article 1 of the Indian Constitution describes India i.e. Bharat as a Union of States and not a Federation of States. Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar in the debate of Constituent Assembly had explained the difference between a Federation and a Union while justifying India as Union of States. He explained, that USA came into existence by the agreement among the northern and southern states States of USA i.e. here American states by coming together through a compact or agreement created a country. Therefore, USA is example of a Federation. In a Federation a State has right to secede from the Federation. Because of this right, American States had to wage a Civil War for keeping all US States under the Federation as some of the US constituent states wanted to secede from the Federation. 


But in the case of India, it is just reverse. After freedom from the British Rule, India came to existence first as a nation and later all the states were created for administrative convenience. By taking example of American Civil War, it was clarified in the Constituent Assembly by Dr. Ambedkar that since India is not a result of agreement among its constituent states and neither any state has right to secede, therefore, India shall be called as " UNION OF STATES".


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Articles

ASSISTANT SECTION OFFICER OR ASO IN CSS : JOB PROFILE, SALARY AND PROMOTION

 Assistant Section Officer (ASO) Assistant Section Officer (ASO) is  called as backbone of the Central Secretariat Services, Government of India. Earlier, ASO was called simply as Assistant. Only in the 2016, DoPT, Government of India has changed the nomenclature of the post from Assistant to Assistant Section Officer. After changing the name of Assistant to ASO in CSS, other Ministries/Departments such as Ministry of External Affairs, Ministry of Railways, Intelligence Bureau (Ministerial) etc followed the same and also renamed post of Assistant as ASO.   Recruitment Process of Assistant Section Officer (ASO) ASOs are appointed under Government of India through two popular methods. One by way of Direct Recruitment and other by way of promoting Senior Secretariat Assistant (erstwhile UDC post) after 10 years of Service or through Departmental Exam. Examinations for the Direct Recruitment of ASOs  is conducted by Staff Selection Commission. Roles and Responsibilities ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Indus Valley Civilization: Beginning of Bronze Age in Indian Sub-continent

 The civilization existed between- 2550 BC- 1500 BC    Period of Mature Harappan Culture – 2550 BC- 1900 BC   Period of Post urban phase of Harappa- 1900 BC- 1500 BC (1200 BC at some places ) The Indus civilisation is also called Harappan because “Dayaram Sahni” in the year 1921 first discovered Harappa, which is presently situated in West Punjab province of Pakistan.   The civilisation was extended over an Area     - 1299600 Square Kilometre which was bigger than contemporary Ancient Egypt & Mesopotamia Civilisation.  Spread over area of the Civilisation was as follows;        North-  Manda in Jammu & Ropar in Punjab        South-  Daimabad in Maharashtra & Bhagatrav in Gujarat i.e. up to Narmada River estuary          East-  Bargaon, Manpur & Allamgirpur in West Meerut district of Uttar Pradesh.        West- Sutkah-Koh ...
1 comment
Read more